Defence strategies against timing and state manipulation attacks

April 2024

Timing and state manipulation attacks stand out for their complexity and the stealth with which they compromise applications. These attacks go after the very core of how an application works, like how it manages its state and the timing of its operations. Attackers can get unauthorized access to or change private information without setting off normal security alarms by taking advantage of flaws in these areas. Vulnerabilities like these can happen because of bad design, mistakes in the code, or missing edge cases in state management and time synchronization… The tricky part about these hacks is that they use the application’s built-in behaviors against it, turning its logic against itself This can happen in many ways, from manipulating time checks to force race conditions, to altering application state in unexpected ways. The consequences are very bad, including data breaches, elevation of privileges and denial of service.  

Why should programmers care? 

It is very important for programmers to understand the details of timing and state manipulation attacks. The challenge includes to fully understand how apps keep state and handle timing in both normal and hostile situations. It is important to understand this in order to create and use strong applications that can withstand such complex attack methods. 

We can’t say enough about how important this information is. It’s easier to take advantage of people, now, that apps are getting more complicated and linked. So, as developers, even if we know that the main focus of a programmer it is to right functional code, we need to adopt a security-first mindset. We need to look at our code through the eyes of an attacker, to find and fix flaws before they happen. This approach includes a commitment to best practices in software development and security, working with a Secure by Design mindset, rigorous testing and continuous learning.  

Protecting against time and state manipulation attacks it requires a complete change in the way software is made and kept up to date. At every stage of the development process, it needs care, skill and a strong commitment to security.  

How do we understand timing and state manipulation attacks? 

The nature of timing attacks is defined by their mechanisms and implications. Timing attacks take advantage of the time variations in executing operations to extract sensitive information from a system. These attacks are subtle, as they do not disrupt the normal function of the application but monitor time differences in processing data. For example, in cryptographic operations, the time to encrypt or decrypt data can vary based on the input and the cryptographic key used. An attacker might measure these time variations to deduce the encryption key without directly breaking the encryption. In web applications, the response time can indirectly reveal whether certain operations, like database queries, were successful, potentially leaking information about the existence of user accounts or sensitive data. 

The complexity of state manipulation attacks stems from their ability to alter application states in unexpected ways. State manipulation attacks exploit the way an application manages its state across interactions, leading to unauthorized outcomes. This form of attack focuses on altering the expected state or flow of an application to trigger unintended behavior. Think to an e-commerce website where the application maintains a user’s shopping cart across sessions. An attacker could manipulate the state, such as the items in the cart or their prices, through various means like intercepting and modifying the data transmitted between the client and server. By doing so, the attacker might gain unauthorized discounts or access to services, exploiting the way the application tracks and updates its state based on user interactions. 

Timing and state manipulation attacks are particularly insidious because they exploit fundamental vulnerabilities in the design and implementation of applications. These vulnerabilities are often overlooked, leading to significant security risks. 

Timing attacks exploit the fact that information can be gleaned from observing how long certain operations take to complete. This is particularly problematic in systems where operation time can reveal sensitive information, such as cryptographic keys or the validity of user credentials. The critical aspect here is that even small differences in processing time, which might seem negligible in everyday operations, can be used to infer critical data about the underlying processes. 

State manipulation attacks target the inconsistencies and flaws in how an application manages its state. This could be due to a lack of stringent checks on the integrity and authenticity of the state throughout the application’s workflow. For example, if an application does not adequately verify the state or data it receives from a user, attackers can manipulate this data to induce the application into an invalid or exploitable state, such as bypassing authentication or authorization checks. 

Identifying vulnerabilities in the applications 

When looking to bolster our application’s defenses against timing and state manipulation attacks, a good starting point is leveraging tools and techniques that help in identifying potential vulnerabilities. 

Chose to implement the Secure by Design methodology. This approach emphasizes the importance of integrating security measures right from the start of development, making sure that security is not overlooked but rather a fundamental aspect of the design and coding process. By adopting security from the beginning, we can better address vulnerabilities that may be targeted by such attacks.  
The next step is to use static and dynamic analysis tools to find any potential vulnerabilities in the application. Static analysis analyzes the code without running it, detecting possible security concerns by identifying code patterns that may result in vulnerabilities. Dynamic analysis, on the other hand, assesses the application while it’s running, which is essential for identifying issues that only arise during actual usage, like timing problems and application state management.  
Let’s not forget also about the significance of code review and penetration testing. By conducting thorough code reviews, preferably with the help of knowledgeable peers, we can detect and resolve issues that automated tools may overlook. Performing penetration testing, which involves simulating attacks on the system, can provide valuable insights. By revealing vulnerabilities from an attacker’s perspective, it helps to gain a clearer understanding of areas that may require stronger defenses against sophisticated attacks. With a programmer’s mindset, this thorough approach begins with Secure by Design and is backed by powerful detection tools and practices. It establishes a solid base for protecting applications from timing and state manipulation threats. 

To defend against timing and state manipulation attacks effectively, it’s important to recognize the code patterns and signatures that are commonly exploited. Vulnerable code patterns, such as those that rely on strict timing for security checks or that do not properly manage application state across different user actions, can often be subtle and easy to overlook. 

Understanding the specific attack vectors used in timing and state manipulation helps in identifying these patterns. For timing attacks, be wary of code that makes security decisions based on the execution time of certain operations. For state manipulation, watch out for areas where the application’s state is not consistently validated or where user input can alter the state in unexpected ways. By familiarizing yourself with these vulnerable patterns and understanding the methods attackers use, you can more effectively scrutinize your code for weaknesses.  

Defensive programming strategies 

To mitigate risks in your applications, adopting secure coding principles is non-negotiable. Let’s see together few examples on how you can better protect against these attacks.  

Start with validating all input to prevent attackers from injecting malicious data. Ensure that you also encode output to avoid XSS attacks. Use parameterized queries to protect against SQL injection. Practice least privilege by granting the minimum permissions necessary for executing operations. For secure time synchronization and management, implement checks that ensure time-related operations do not become a vector for attacks. Use time synchronization protocols like NTP, but with added security measures to prevent manipulation. When handling application state, ensure that state transitions are explicit and validate state changes to avoid unauthorized modifications. Employ session management techniques that securely manage user states across interactions, using tokens that are securely generated and invalidated after use. Encryption and hashing are your first lines of defense in protecting data integrity. Use strong, modern encryption algorithms for data at rest and in transit and apply hashing to securely store sensitive information like passwords. Implementing secure random number generation is also critical, especially for timing operations, to prevent attackers from predicting or influencing outcomes that should be random. 

Ensure that your applications run in secure execution environments, isolating sensitive operations from potentially compromised system components. This isolation helps protect against both direct attacks and side-channel attacks, including those targeting timing and state information. 

A call to action 

Adopt Secure by Design to make security a core part of software from the start, not just an afterthought. This means bringing in security measures early on in the design phase and keeping them in focus all through development. It’s a way to spot and fix issues sooner and make sure the final product is solid and safe. Putting Secure by Design into practice means integrating security steps into every phase of your project. This includes planning for threats early, sticking to security best practices while coding, doing regular security checks and managing configurations safely.  

Our call to action is about changing how we see app development. It’s about understanding that security is just as important as making sure the app works well. We need to prioritize security from the very beginning, supporting our security experts in the process. Security is not solely their responsibility, it’s a collective effort that requires all of us to contribute, making our apps both superior in functionality and robust in safety. 

We shouldn’t see security as a scary or boring topic that only a few people need to worry about. Instead, it’s something that should excite programmers, business developers and project managers alike. To build apps that aren’t just great to use but are also safe, we need a strong team. A team that talks about cybersecurity every day, in a way that’s easy to understand and act on, making sure security is part of the plan from day one. By bringing everyone on board with this mindset, we’re adding an extra layer of protection to our apps and we’re making security a natural part of our conversation and work process. This way, we’re all working together to make our products the best they can be, safe and sound. It’s about building something we’re proud of, together, every step of the way. 

Contact us, at Cybalgoris, for a more in-depth training for threats, vulnerabilities and for a very original solution for Secure by Design. 

Request a phone appointment